Mukasey Acknowledges Information From Syria Cannot Be Trusted

July 23, 2008, New York – Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) Senior Attorney Maria LaHood, who represents Maher Arar in the U.S., issued the following statement in response to Attorney General Michael Mukasey’s Comments before Congress today:

“Mr. Mukasey testified today that given Syria’s history, he finds it ‘somewhat unlikely that somebody would hope to get anything out of anything that went on in Syria,’ apparently acknowledging that the United States could not trust the results of any interrogation in Syria because of its history of torture. Yet nearly in the same breath, Mr. Mukasey placed reliance on ‘assurances’ from Syria regarding how Mr. Arar was to be treated there. Mr. Mukasey testified that sending Maher ‘to Syria was safer, provided that we got the assurances - and it’s my understanding that we did.’

“These are the same ‘assurances’ that the Department of Homeland Security Inspector General found were ambiguous, in addition to finding that the U.S. apparently failed to examine the ‘validity’ of the ‘assurances.’

“Sending Maher to Syria instead of home to Canada was certainly not safer for him, and did nothing to make the United States safer. Although not surprising, it is still disappointing that Mr. Mukasey is currently refusing to appoint an outside special counsel to do an independent investigation of Maher’s rendition to Syria. The tendency of the Department of Justice to cover up its crimes is exactly why an outside prosecutor is needed.”

For more information on Mr. Arar’s case, visit the Arar v. Ashcroft case page.

The Center for Constitutional Rights works with communities under threat to fight for justice and liberation through litigation, advocacy, and strategic communications. Since 1966, the Center for Constitutional Rights has taken on oppressive systems of power, including structural racism, gender oppression, economic inequity, and governmental overreach. Learn more at


Last modified 

July 28, 2011