Bush Torture Indictment

Synopsis

Switzerland

On February 7, 2011, two torture victims were to have filed criminal complaints for torture against former president George W. Bush in Geneva, who was due to speak at an event there on February 12th.  On the eve of the filing of the complaints, George Bush cancelled his trip.  Swiss law requires the presence of the alleged torturer on Swiss soil before a preliminary investigation can be open.  The complaints could not be filed after Bush cancelled, as the basis for jurisdiction no longer existed.

These two complaints are part of a larger effort to ensure accountability for torturers, including former U.S. officials.  So on February 7, 2011, CCR publically released the "Preliminary Bush Torture Indictment."   This document presents fundamental aspects of the case against George Bush for torture, and a preliminary legal analysis of his liability for torture and a response to some anticipated defenses.   This document will be updated as developments warrant.  The exhibit list contains references to more than 2,500 pages of supporting material.

Canada

Watch Bush admit he authorized torture and say he would do it again in this televised interview on NBC:

Status

On April 20, 2012, CCR and CCIJ submitted a report to the United Nations Committee Against Torture, which is set to review Canada's compliance with its obligations under the Convention Against Torture in May 2012.  The report sets forth Canada's failure to comply with its obligations to initiate criminal proceedings against Mr. Bush during his visit to Canada in October 2011, after it was presented with a draft indictment and supporting materials setting forth the legal and factual basis for a case of torture.  The report calls upon the Committee to investigate the role of various Canadian officials in deciding against initiating an investigation against Bush and to make strong recommendations to ensure that signatories of CAT abide by their obligations under the Convention to prosecute torturers present in their territory so as to further the Convention's aim of ending impunity for torture. 

On November 14, 2012 on behalf of four torture survivors, CCR and CCIJ filed a complaint against Canada with the United Nations Committee against Torture for the country’s failure to investigate and prosecute former President George W. Bush during his 2011 visit to British Columbia. This filing marked the first time a complaint concerning torture allegations against a high-level U.S. official has been filed with the U.N. Committee. 

On January 22, 2013, the UN CAT informed the plaintiffs that the complaint has been registered with the Committee, and a copy has been communicated to Canada for its response.  Under the Committee Rules, Canada has two months to provide information and observations on the admissibility of the complaint.

Description

There is global support for the victims of torture under the Bush administration to seek justice and accountability. 

Switzerland

In February 2011, CCR worked with the Berlin-based European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights to prepare the case in Switzerland, and had support from the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH). 

The individual complaints that were set to be filed in Geneva on February 7, 2011 were supported by a letter from more than 60 human rights organizations and prominent individuals calling for the prosecution of George W. Bush for torture, including former UN Special Rapporteur on Torture, Theo van Boven, UN Special Rapporteur on Independence of Judges and Lawyers, Leandro Despouy, and Nobel Peace Prize recipients Shirin Ebadi and Pérez Esquivel. A number of the human rights organizations which signed on are facing the on-going harms of the “counterterrorism” policies advanced under the Bush administration and then adopted or employed in their own countries.

Manfred Nowak, former UN Special Rapporteur on Torture (2004-2010), was to submit an expert opinion on the complaints concluding that the conduct to which both plaintiffs were subjected constitutes torture, that Switzerland had an obligation to open a preliminary investigation, and that George W. Bush enjoys no immunity.

Canada

In September 2011, CCR partnered with the Canadian Centre for International Justice (CCIJ) and submitted a letter and Indictment to Canada’s Attorney General, urging him to prosecute George W. Bush for crimes of torture if he travels to Canada as scheduled on October 20, 2011. According to the Indictment,  former President Bush bears individual and command responsibility for the acts of his subordinates, which he ordered, authorized, condoned, or otherwise aided and abetted, as well as for violations committed by his subordinates, which he failed to prevent or punish. In particular, Bush is alleged to have authorized or overseen enforced disappearance and secret detention, extraordinary rendition, waterboarding, exposure to extreme temperatures, sleep deprivation, punching, kicking, isolation in “coffin” cells for prolonged periods, threats of bad treatment, solitary confinement, and forced nudity.

Timeline